Archive for April, 2011


Karl Quote

There is now no escaping a Monstrous Economic Contraction

Hmmm… so what exactly constitutes a monstrous contraction?

How bad would it get?  Define it.

… well I can give a guesstimate of just how big a contraction would be – although that’s just an opinion.

But on one point at least, I don’t think there can be any debate. The contraction is coming, and indeed is already underway. The debate now isn’t when we will get a recovery, it is how much deeper this recession/depression is going to get.

In large part, the economic situation in NZ is going to be predicated upon what happens in the rest of the world, particularly the United States, so their depression and contraction is our contraction too.

But more specifically:  (feel free to insert your own figures)

Currently the NZ government is reported to be borrowing $300 million a week to fund current spending.

That will stop, one way or another, and then we get to see what our economy looks like without that sort of constant injection of cash. The economy is going to contract by 52 x $300 mil per year…

Hmmm, that’s $15 billion a year. What’s our GDP again???

Next, lets look at the PIIGS – Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece, Spain.

Portugal and Ireland are looking at interest rates for government borrowing into the low teens. Greece is at 20 percent.  (Update 30/8/11 – as of a day ago, the latest figure I saw was 60% on One Year Bonds… Opps)

So tack on several more percentage points for commercial rates…

If NZ follows the same trend, and the fundamental numbers suggest we are in completely the same boat, then mortgage rates here are destined to hit the high to mid teens in the not too distant future. Businesses and mortgages will be paying circa 15%+ .  That will double and triple the interest payments on borrowed money.

The NZ reserve bank would have the raw numbers somewhere, but basically the calculus is like this. If there is $100 billion of mortgages in NZ, and there are on average paying 5% interest, then that is $5 billion tax on the national income to service the debt. A 15% interest rate means an additional $10 billion hit/contraction to our economy.

Additionally, a jump of that magnitude in interest rates would kill the Real-Estate market (but existing mortgages still need to be serviced). New sales and mortgage volumes would collapse, but more importantly, so would the existing prices of property. How much? At a minimum I would say between 10 and 20%, but I don’t see any reason why house and property prices couldn’t ultimately collapse by 50%.

If that were to happen, then that is not too far different from saying our economy/national wealth would contract by 50%.

However, that is a different thing from GDP, and we shall try and stick with that type of metric in the meantime. So, just concentrating on our income from goods and services, less our expenses, what else needs to go into the pot?

Oil. I don’t pretend to know where the international price for oil is going to go, but the price has jumped over 20% in the last year or so. (if you have more exact figures, please do share them). If the price of oil continues to climb then that is not just a direct cost for the purchase of it, but also has a chilling effect on the rest of the economy. But for now, lets just say that a notional, national oil bill of $10 billion is now costing an additional $2 billion (20%).

On the positive side, rises in food commodity prices means a boost to our national income. But for the sake of my analysis, I will balance that against a fall in inbound tourist dollars. I would not be surprised to see visitor numbers ultimately drop by 50% from their peak numbers of several years ago.

There are always any number of other “invisibles” that central Banks like to quote.

But also leaving that aside for the moment, lets look at what we have got already.

– 15 billion,  (halt to govt borrowing and spending)

– 2 billion,  (increase in govt debt servicing)

– 10 billion,  (increase in private debt servicing)

– 2 billion,  (increased oil import cost)

lets just leave it at that for the moment and tot it up.

We are looking at some $30 billion+  contraction of our economy.

Divide that by the GDP and you have an indication of what sort of contraction of our economy we are looking at.

Interestingly, when I go to the Statistics NZ website and look up GDP, they can give me all sorts of percentage movements there have been in GDP, but nowhere could I find the gross number… mmmm…

Anyway, the Dollar numbers I have used here are just plucked from mid air. I recommend you do your own research and find out just how much money could be sucked out of our economy very very quickly.

And then tell me if that amounts to a monstrous contraction or not.

I would suggest that some $30 billion exiting our economy (per annum) would have a very chilling effect.

(I also think that estimate is likely conservative)

Rug up warm.


Also, requires we don’t get any natural disasters, earthquakes etc… Ohh, wait…!



Interestingly enough, not long after I wrote this, Bernard Hickey wrote an article with some real figures in it. Interesting to compare and contrast…

Forecasts Hard to Believe

The government has forecast a return to budget surplus by 2014/15 and the creation of 170,000 jobs. It has forecast economic growth will rise to 4 per cent, helping to control its borrowing. Here’s five reasons these forecasts are not believable and why the Government will need to cut spending harder and raise taxes either next year or in 2013 to fix its structural deficit.

The de-leveraging drag

New Zealand households and businesses have changed their approach to spending and debt. They are avoiding borrowing and repaying debt at every opportunity. This is suppressing any economic rebound from the global financial crisis. Some analysis suggests this de-leveraging drag could lower economic growth by between 1 per cent and 2 per cent of GDP for up to a decade after the 2008 crisis. This is not reflected in the Treasury’s forecasts.

Household debt to disposable income remains only marginally below its record highs of almost 160 per cent. A drop back to the 100 per cent levels seen in the early 2000s would suppress domestic and retail spending and spending in construction.

Banking the payments

The Government has argued $15 billion worth of reinsurance payments, spending during the Rugby World Cup and the commodity price boom windfall for farmers will boost growth.

However, there are already signs homeowners, businesses and farmers are choosing to put their insurance payments and Fonterra payouts in the bank to repay debt, rather than rebuild immediately or spend money on consumption.

Bank executives have become nervous in recent weeks about a lack of net lending growth as households refuse to take on extra risk when they know interest rates are unlikely to drop any further and house prices are flat to falling in most parts of New Zealand, except for central Auckland.

Slow earthquake rebuild

The Government is assuming more than $20 billion worth of earthquake rebuilding will surge through the economy over the next three to five years. But there remain doubts about how quickly the land stability issue can be finalised and whether the Christchurch CBD will be rebuilt to anything like its previous capacity. The rebuild after the September 4 quake was surprisingly slow and the enormity of the task after the February 22 quake confounds many.

Global growth fears

Treasury’s forecasts depend on continued strong growth in China and recoveries in America and Europe. However, there are fresh doubts about China’s ability to control an inflationary surge and the European sovereign debt crisis continues to bubble along. America has also failed to bounce out of its recession with any vigour.

The slide seen in commodity prices in recent weeks is one symptom of those doubts.

Dairy powder prices have already fallen 12 per cent from their peaks in March.

IRD forecast much less

The Inland Revenue Department forecast revenues would be $4 billion lower than the revenues forecast by Treasury over the next five years. The IRD saw lower corporate tax revenues in later years, yet the Government chose to use the rosier Treasury forecasts.

The risks are economic growth and, therefore, tax revenues will be less than expected, leaving the Budget mired in deficits and the Government borrowing heavily from foreign creditors, including the People’s Bank of China.

This is not the balanced, cautious approach promoted by John Key and Bill English. They may find themselves redoing the numbers soon after the November 26 election.

Bernard Hickey



Read Full Post »

(CHS essay – click link for full article).

Our “Let’s Pretend” Economy 

There are two economies–the real one, which is in decline, and the “let’s pretend” one touted by the State and corporate propaganda machines. Children love to play “let’s pretend.” Let’s pretend the economy is “recovering.”

Why does this “recovery” remind me of an addict who’s conning his caseworker? (Yes, I’m really in recovery–those aren’t tracks, they’re insect bites….)

Let’s play pretend that jobs are really really coming back…

Let’s pretend that households, corporations and government are reducing their debt…

Let’s pretend that wages are rising…

Let’s pretend your purchasing power isn’t in a free-fall…

Let’s pretend unemployment is falling…

Let’s pretend corporate profits are the most important metric of our financial well-being…

Let’s pretend those great profits trickle down to the greater good… to pension funds that benefit workers everywhere…

How much longer are we willing to play “let’s pretend”?

Eventually we’ll have to return to the grown-up world and deal with reality.

~ Charles Hugh Smith


Read Full Post »


 There’s no way out of the box – that doesn’t result in a monstrous economic contraction folks:
(short and sweet, the headline says it all – and that which applies to the Americans, applies to us also…)
Government borrowing to try and avert/delay it has about run its course, the Monstrous Economic Contraction has started.
(most people still haven’t got a clue)
Que Sera…

Read Full Post »



So, amid all the Spin about “economic recovery”in the MSM, just a couple of news items from today.


[from Zero Hedge]

“Failure by Congress to raise the U.S. debt limit “could plunge the world economy back into recession,” President Barack Obama declared Friday. Obama urged swift action, saying he doesn’t want the United States to get close to a deadline that would destabilize financial markets. He said he was confident Congress ultimately would raise the limit. “We always have. We will do it again,” said Obama, who voted against raising the debt limit as a freshman senator from Illinois.”

For those keeping score… this merely underscores that the president is now in contention for the Nobel Prize in hypocrisy: after all compare this statement to Obama’s now supremely ironic remark from March 20, 2006:

The fact that we are here today to debate raising America’s debt limit is a sign of leadership failure. It is a sign that the U.S. Government can’t pay its own bills. It is a sign that we now depend on ongoing financial assistance from foreign countries to finance our Government’s reckless fiscal policies. … Increasing America’s debt weakens us domestically and internationally. Leadership means that ‘the buck stops here. Instead, Washington is shifting the burden of bad choices today onto the backs of our children and grandchildren. America has a debt problem and a failure of leadership. Americans deserve better.” 


Hmmm, okayyyy…

so apparently…

The Global Economy is Completely Dependent on Washington’s Ability to Borrow and Spend…?

and a failure to be able to do so means – there is no recovery


Or, then there is this story:

Tell me again how plunging volume of trades is a good thing?

Tell me why there is no connection between the US govt printing money and stocks rising – but at the same time, real people using their own money are backing out of stockmarkets as fast as they can.

Tell me again that it isn’t all just computer algorithms and government money (borrowing) holding the whole fake edifice up.

Tell me again about how the worlds economy is recovering…

Yeah, right!


We are screwed, and we are seriously near to the end of the path where Spin and Optimism can continue to hold off the apocalypse.


But hey, if you think I am wrong, feel free to tell me why in the comments section below…

Read Full Post »


And so it begins here as well.

TBTF – To Big To Fail.

We have just had AMI insurance go tits-up.  They haven’t actually come out and point blank said it has failed, but it has. otherwise the Government wouldn’t have had to leap in and guarantee all policy holders in a “surprise” announcement.

Instead the government has said that they have had no choice but to step in to ensure stability. There is no stability of course. The government is just pretenting. The whole “extend and pretent” – “kick the can” game continues a bit further.

But when the government is continuing to borrow $300 million a week just to keep the economy’s nose above water, there is no stability and there is no security. We are on the brink. That is why they said they “had” to step in, they know exactly what the consequences of a failure of AMI would be.

The financial consequences would ripple and cascade through the economy and start a domino effect of failures.

They did have a choice however, but they chose to step in and backstop AMI.

Because it was Too Big to let fail.

Or rather, the political implications were too big for them to risk letting it fail.

(you know – they would have lost the election – that risk, the really important stuff)

Unfortunately, it will still fail, but we (as in – all of us as tax payers and citizens) will have to pick up the bill. That way the costs can be hidden and diluted. I guess you can call that a kind of re-insurance policy – unlike what AMI did when they were the industries lowest re-insurers.

Via a deliberate policy decision by the managers of the company, they under re-insured their risk and it has come back to bite them on the bum.

Are they now in handcuffs???

Of course not – no one is ever to blame are they.

All the big financial players have the system very nicely gamed, they always have an out-clause where they get off scott free.

There is always a Black Swan to blame and unforeseeable circumstances isn’t there <sarc>.

But unless EVERYONE has to pay the full and final costs of their mistakes, then the consequences of this sort of bullshit will continue to be passed off and hidden.

But it is no co-incidence that at the same time as we are reporting this sort of shit, we are also reporting record unemployment, poverty and stress in the most vulnerable sectors of our society.

Government HAS TO STOP bailing out the too-big-to-fail institutions and businesses. Yes it will hurt – bigtime.

But there literally is not option anymore. Because bailing out wont stop the hurt, that is still coming anyway.

But the wrong people will end up bearing the brunt of it.

AMI has failed(and it HAS failed) because the managers and the regulators didn’t do their damn job properly.

They should be all fired, or in prison.

Even all the “innocent” policy holders should be cut adrift and left to fail.

I truely don’t care that they are “innocent” in all this and paid their premiums on time, etc etc.

Until such time as the is enough agony inflicted, there simply wont be the proper attention paid to how this whole business is being conducted. Those policy holders are going to have to be sacrificed to force us to focus on the real problem.


ALL OF THEM – their business model does not stand up to the global financial reality.

And we can not bail them all out, there isn’t enough money in the world, let alone in NZ.

Every financial institution in the world and every Central Bank is desperately paddling flat-out to obscure and get around the facts, but the implosion has started. Look out below.

The Bailouts of the TBTF is simply lies, evasion and obfuscation to try and avoid dealing with reality.

It is also, incidentally, a very subtle rip off and theft – and you are the patsy.


Read Full Post »